Sexual assault bench book on judicial commission website. Section 353i of the constitution provides that an accused person has the right to adduce and challenge evidence. The right of crossexamination is a statutory right which vests in a party to the proceedings. A defendant must not be crossexamined about a matter that is relevant to the assessment of the defendants credibility, unless the court gives leave. Following are sample transcripts that include the states direct examination as well the defense attorneys cross examination of state experts. The project gutenberg ebook of the art of crossexamination, by. Crossexamination in south african law traces the history of crossexamination and focuses on the substantive law relating to crossexamination. Dec 28, 2016 the right of crossexamination is a statutory right which vests in a party to the proceedings.
Topics covered include the problems related to an unrepresented accused in respect of cross examination and the difficulties which flow from having evidence translated. The challenging of evidence is through crossexamination. This meant that leave in order to question the complainant on such matter could only be granted in very limited circumstances. Selfrepresented accused judicial commission of nsw. Oct 30, 2019 but around the country, discipline practices on many campuses dont include any form of crossexamination, and can be very frustrating for accused students who say their sexual. Cross examination cross examination of witnesses called by the opposing party is an absolute right in both civil and criminal cases. Perry mason used crossexamination as an investigative tool to search for the real murderer.
Trial advocacy, crossexamination of a medical expert. It requires not only extensive preparation but also a delicate balance between aggressively discrediting the witness on the one. Cross examination is a vital part of defending those accused of sexual crimes. The party who has a right to take part in any enquiry, or trial, can crossexamine the witnesses. Crossexamination of eyewitnesses james education center. The questioning of a witness or party during a trial, hearing, or deposition by the party opposing the one who asked the person to testify in order to evaluate the truth of that persons testimony, to develop the testimony further, or to accomplish any other objective. One of the most effective tests for the discovery of the truth to test whether the evidence given by a witness is true or not cross examination is not the only way to ascertain the truthfulness of a witness. Lets try an easier one then, what are the two different sets of legal elements required to be proven during the evidentiary phase of a criminal trial where the accused is charged with allegedly. Science and techniques, second edition, larry pozner and roger dodd continue their outstanding tradition of helping attorneys conduct commanding cross examinations. Eliciting positive facts known to the witness that help your case or damage your opponents case.
The right of confrontation is the basis of cross examination. Eichmann trial session 100 cross examination of the accused. The paper considers the dynamics and potential impact of such cross. Crossexamination is a vital part of defending those accused of sexual crimes. I presume it is the experience of every author, after his first book is published. On cross examination, however, it is usually impossible to rehearse, so you will have to rely on meticulous preparation. Based on the sum total of the tests and interviews, you and the others decided that the child had been abused.
Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. However, while the right to crossexamination is broad, counsel are generally bound by the rules of relevancy and materiality r. Sample cross examination cross examination at trial of alleged victims of sexual crimes is an extraordinarily sensitive task. Cross examination in south african law traces the history of cross examination and focuses on the substantive law relating to cross examination. Crossexamination is a dangerous foray behind enemy lines. Reid claims that in normal conversation persons make eye contact 3060% of the time but deceptive persons avert their gaze. On crossexamination, however, it is usually impossible to rehearse, so you will have to rely on meticulous preparation. On direct examination, witnesses are controlled through preparation and rehearsal. Its quite comprehensive, and will certainly make you a better cross examiner or just help you get a good grade in your trial class. Crossexamination of arresting officer principles, custody, motor vehicle stops and searches, drug cases, search warrants, and searches incident to arrests by kevin j. Mahoney to amp up your crossexamination in your next criminal case. Cross examination intends to explore the evidence of the witness, exposing weaknesses, biases, and inaccuracies, and thereby assist in the truth finding process. There are two main reasons for doing a cross examination. That protocol is made up of interviews, tests, etc.
Supreme and district courts benchbook unrepresented defendant. Rights iccpr embody the right of the accused to crossexamine witnesses. In my experience, if a case is going to be won, it is usually during the prosecution case. Crossexamination,the rarest, the most useful, and the most difficult to be acquired of. The art of cross examination is a classic text for trial attorneys and law students on how to cross examine witnesses. Judge landau warns the attorney general that the matter concerning the liquidation of the ghettos is being dealt with a second time. Mitchell, 2008 onca 757 canlii, 2008 onca 757, paras. According to section 7 of the indian evidence act, the examination of a witness by the adverse party shall be called his crossexamination. The art of crossexamination plays an important role in the trial of each case which involves hard work and talent of lawyers while providing justice to their clients. Before conducting the cross examination of an expert witness, the criminal defense attorney must become an expert in forensic evidence as well as the basic principals of forensics. Mastering the art of crossexamination l earning to be a lawyer was often by doing. Reexamination means the examination of a witness, subsequent to the crossexamination by the party who called him, shall be called his reexamination. Counsel for the accused had commenced his crossexamination of the witness, but had not completed it at the time of the witnesss death.
You have the right to crossexamine a crown witness. There are two main reasons for doing a crossexamination. Wellman goes through both the theory and practical wisdom of cross examination, giving stories and examples to drive the point home. An accused cannot personally crossexamine children under 16, intellectually impaired witnesses, or the victim of a sexual or violent offence. Pdf the right to crossexamination and witness protection in. Despite subsection 2, leave is not required for crossexamination by the prosecutor about whether the defendant.
Crossexamining complainants in sexual assault proceedings public defenders criminal law conference 2009 paper by belinda rigg, public defender 1. Crossexamination by larry pozner overdrive rakuten. Mastering the art of crossexamination bakerhostetler. If youre representing yourself that is, you dont have a lawyer in a supreme court trial, you might have to ask the other persons witnesses questions. A selfrepresented accused must not crossexamine a vulnerable person unless the court grants leave. Sample cross examination crossexamination at trial of alleged victims of sexual crimes is an extraordinarily sensitive task. The right of an accused to be represented by counsel in a trial, other than. The cross examination of complainants in sexual cases as to their sexual history was limited by s 41 1 of. Cross examination is a dangerous foray behind enemy lines. So then you do heavy manual work in your occupation. Canadian criminal procedure and practicetrialsexaminations.
The cross examination is a cornerstone of the adversarial trial process and is a fundamental feature of a fair trial. Sample crossexamination of sexual assault victim part 1. This transcript is a second pretrial hearing involving the same case of alleged child sexual abuse. The second edition offers deeper analysis of crossexamination methods, with more integration and interrelationship of techniques and principles. Following are sample transcripts that include the states direct examination as well the defense attorneys crossexamination of state experts. Science and techniques, second edition, larry pozner and roger dodd continue their outstanding tradition of helping attorneys conduct commanding crossexaminations. When a prosecution witness is called and sworn they will give their evidence to the court in the first instance. It can be your best friend or your worst enemy if handled incorrectly. Buy the art of cross examination book online at best prices in india on. Crossexamining the expert witness with the aid of books.
Secondly, the formulated plan must be in harmony with the circumstances of the case and the special nature of the testimony. See also judicial commission of nsw, equality before the law bench book. Crossexamination in south african law lexisnexis sa. Mahoney excerpted from relentless criminal crossexamination i. Except where the accused places his characater at issue, the crown cannot cross examine the witness on the accused of the prior criminal record.
Crossexamining the expert witness with the aid of books sherwin willens in matters of science the reasonings of men of science can only be answered by men of science. During crossexamination, the eyewitness is unlikely to admit that he could be incorrect. Sep 17, 2012 free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. The secrets of crossexamination the toughest part of being a trial attorney, whether criminal or civil, is pulling off an excellent cross. For more trial advocacy tips that will help you persuade. Finally, children are easily accused of being poor witnesses, as being confused, untruthful and having fallible memories. Except where the accused places his character at issue, the crown cannot crossexamine the witness on the accused of the prior criminal record. Omission or contradiction are highlighted at the time of cross examination only by the cross examine lawyer. Cross examination by an accused this fact sheet contains information on the procedure to be followed when you are defending a criminal charge and cross examining a prosecution witness. Cross examination by an accused this fact sheet contains information on the procedure to be followed when you are defending a criminal charge and crossexamining a prosecution witness. At the end of the states case, counsel for the accused applied for discharge of the accused in terms of s 174. Sample crossexamination transcripts criminal defense wiki.
In criminal law proceedings the right to crossexamination is guaranteed by s 353i of the constitution and by s 166 of the criminal procedure act. Under s 15yf, a selfrepresented accused is prohibited from crossexamining a vulnerable person, and a person appointed by the court is to ask him or her any questions sought to be put by the accused. But around the country, discipline practices on many campuses dont include any form of crossexamination, and can be very frustrating for accused students who say their sexual. In the 1970s, when carolyn lamm, one of the contributors to this book, and i shared a cramped office in the justice department, we were given 60 files, and told to file lawsuits where appro priate, try the cases where necessary, and come back for more when we. The gynocentric and womenprotecting system will always try not to let the cases reach this stage and which is the reason the so called counselling by cawmahila thana etc. For the criminal defence lawyer, there are few things more important than cross examination.
Sample cross examination new york criminal lawyer zachary. Crossexamining complainants in sexual assault proceedings. The accused person will normally be referred to as x but the term the accused will be used where the use of the abbreviation x might be confusing. Basic crossexamination techniques in matrimonial cases like.
A right to crossexamine a witness even can arise when a witness even can arise when a witness speaks against ones interest who calls him. Buy the art of cross examination book online at low prices in. The art of crossexamination is a classic text for trial attorneys and law students on how to crossexamine witnesses. For the criminal defence lawyer, there are few things more important than crossexamination. Crossexamination intends to explore the evidence of the witness, exposing weaknesses, biases, and inaccuracies, and thereby assist in the truth finding process. Wellman, the book was first published in 1903 by the macmillan company, and was still in print more than 100 years later. The crown can ask the accused of the date and place of conviction. Canadian criminal evidencecredibilityprior criminal record. Information about crossexamining witnesses if you go to supreme court without a lawyer, plus sample questions to ask. Choates crossexamination of russell sage in the third.
Crossexamination causes captain queeg to reveal his mental instability in the caine mutiny. The second edition offers deeper analysis of cross examination methods, with more integration and interrelationship of techniques and principles. Sep 22, 2014 apply these proven strategies excerpted from relentless criminal crossexamination, by kevin j. The crossexamination is a cornerstone of the adversarial trial process and is a fundamental feature of a fair trial. A jury may not use the conviction of a coaccused for the same charge as evidence towards guilt, rather it may only be used to assess the accuseds knowledge and intent. The cross examination of complainants in sexual cases as to their sexual history was limited by s 41 1 of the youth justice and criminal evidence act, 1999. Wellman goes through both the theory and practical wisdom of crossexamination, giving stories and examples to drive the point home. The objects of crossexamination of a nonexpert fact witness include the following. While a plaintiff can score points with an impressive, forthright expert, the crossexamination of a defendants expert if it reveals that witness is dishonest or dishonorable can anger the jury and provide the most lasting memories of the trial. Introduction crossexamination is a weapon, an effective weapon if handled correctly and a dangerous weapon if not. There are many books on crossexamination and many lists of the. The subject of crossexamination is one of vital importance in the conduct of law cases because only it has the power to sift the truth from falsehood. Eichmann trial session 100 crossexamination of the accused. In offering this book to the legal profession i do not intend to arrogate to.
Sample questions to ask when crossexamining witnesses at a. Crossexamination legal definition of crossexamination. Principles, custody, motor vehicle stops and searches, drug. Like a weapon, it must be treated with respect and understanding. It contains direct and cross examination of the same alleged victim a month and a half after the first hearing. Before conducting the crossexamination of an expert witness, the criminal defense attorney must become an expert in forensic evidence as. Its quite comprehensive, and will certainly make you a better crossexaminer or just help you get a good grade in your trial class. Film footage begins in the middle of the session 100.
However, while the right to cross examination is broad, counsel are generally bound by the rules of relevancy and materiality r. It usually consists of two kinds of questions 1 those designed to bring out additional facts and details about the events that were not brought out during the direct. It requires not only extensive preparation but also a delicate balance between aggressively discrediting the witness on the one hand and respecting her as a person on the other. Crossexamination crossexamination of witnesses called by the opposing party is an absolute right in both civil and criminal cases. Normally, examination in chief and cross examination are made in the same day unless allowed to be withheld with the court for some other date. Cross examining complainants in sexual assault proceedings public defenders criminal law conference 2009 paper by belinda rigg, public defender 1. Eichmann trial session 96 crossexamination of the accused. They promote concepts of neurolinguistic programming. Hausner continues with the cross examination of the accused. A jury may not use the conviction of a co accused for the same charge as evidence towards guilt, rather it may only be used to assess the accuseds knowledge and intent. Cross examination is probably the most important stage where false cases filed by wives can get demolished and at the end of it what looked like kevlar plated armour of a wifes case looks worse than torn underwear. Cross examinations in rape and sexual offence cases.
678 316 901 875 893 950 1352 419 384 1388 422 465 501 1302 1524 622 881 486 37 218 313 1089 476 752 1471 776 215 1073 1323 1417 543 352