The problem of normative authority in kant, hegel, and nietzsche paul katsafanas forthcoming in nietzsches engagements with kant, volume i. This book should not be missed by anyone interested in political philosophy. Huemers central insight is that what political scientists call legitimacy, or what he calls political authority, is the most important stronghold that advocates of anarchocapitalism have to overcome in order to win the intellectual battle. The tanzimat and the problem of political authority in the ottoman empire, 18391876 kevin goodwin history honors thesis may, 2006. Social contract theory and the problems of contract vitiation in citizens and constituted authority relationship. Michael huemer is the author of the problem of political authority 4. Michael huemer author of the problem of political authority. In 2012, the libertarian bookshelf was expanded by a number of notable academic works.
Penultimate version for final authoritative version, please refer to text published in mind. Michael huemers 20 book the problem of political authority sets out to prove a radical conjecture. An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey. Ive read almost every major work of libertarian political philosophy ever published. Marvin is in need of food, without which he will suffer from malnutrition or starvation. The consequentialist explanation of political authority contends that great social. By using government services such as roads, schools, and police. The problem of normative authority bu personal websites.
Language english format pdf pages 365 isbn 97817281661 file size 3. In my view, michael huemers new the problem of political authority. Barry, norman, an introduction to modern political theory. How does huemer respond to the claim that drug use harms third parties.
He claims that we should not prohibit all behavior that harms third parties in any way. In my view, michael huemer s new the problem of political authority. Introduction michael huemers the problem of political authority addresses the question of whether the state is, or can be, legitimate. Huemer scrupulously reasons from widely shared moral premises to surprising conclusions.
Review of michael huemers the problem of political authority. The term authority identifies political legitimacy, which grants and justifies the. Get free shipping on the problem of political authority by michael huemer, from. At the time i thought it was pretty clever and hes since published it in social philosophy and policy, so i thought id go ahead and share it here. My aim in what follows will not be to show that an anarchic society could survive in any and all political climates. Huemer scrupulously reasons from widely shared moral. Political authority is only one aspect of figuring out whether the state is justified. The problem of political authority by michael huemer econlib. After all, huemer isnt the only one who thinks a duty to obey is a part of political authority. Considering nearly everyone allows some role for government, huemer has set himself a tall task. Power, authority and the state 7 also an important concept in political sociology. If, like me, you think anarchocapitalism sounds ridiculous, this is the book for you. Bryan caplan praises michael huemers work on the problem of political authority because it avoids the extremes of both rightsbased and consequentialist reasoning. This is part of the social contract, which is a kind of agreement between citizens and the government, whereby the citizens agree to pay taxes and obey the laws, in return for the governments protection.
Dunn, john, the history of political theory and other essays. A lack of political authority means that we are not obligated to obey the law merely because it is the law we have other moral reasons not to murder or steal, though, and that agents of the state are not morally entitled to coerce citizens in ways that private citizens are morally prohibited from doing. Under the terms of the traditional social contract theory, then, political obligation is a species of contractual obligation. Each has notoriously foundered on difficult problems in the past, as is. He uses the term awareness in a technical sense, as the relation between one who is aware and the object of which he is aware. It shouldnt come as a surprise that groups with substantial political power are. My aim will be to show that an anarchic society could survive in some realistic conditions, conditions that obtain in some parts of the world or could reasonably be expected to obtain in the future. He allows that certain restrictions should be placed on what one may do while intoxicated. So that sounds like question begging, but i think the antirealist could argue that the mere counterfactually would have a. Aug 28, 2016 michael huemer on political authority by j. If it is wrong to punish people for engaging in a certain behavior, then it is wrong to punish them for doing things that might lead to this behavior.
The problem of political authority michael huemer bok. One key figure who favored the policy to return to this traditional framework was a late seventeenth and early eighteenth century ottoman. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link. An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey by michael huemer. Jan 17, 20 ive read almost every major work of libertarian political philosophy ever published. This establishes that one must be aware of something if there is no object present, then there cannot be actual awareness.
The theory holds that, at least in some countries, there is a contractual relationship between the government and its citizens. The ottoman elite had long focused on traditional reforms. In the exercise of governance, the terms authority and power sometimes are inaccurately used as synonyms. Nearly all political discourse presupposes that the government has a special kind of authority to issue commands to the rest of society, huemer writes in his preface. Michael huemers challenge to the legitimacy of government. An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey palgrave macmillan 20, michael huemer explores this puzzling phenomenon, and defends the. Jan 29, 20 huemers central insight is that what political scientists call legitimacy, or what he calls political authority, is the most important stronghold that advocates of anarchocapitalism have to overcome in order to win the intellectual battle. I argue that taxation for redistributive purposes is a property rights violation, responding to arguments due to nagel, murphy, sunstein, and holmes claiming. And perhaps you are unaware of all the ways in which philosophers have tried to support the idea that political authority is justified. At bryan caplans recommendation, i have been reading michael huemers book the problem of political authority.
An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey is the best book in the genre. Political will defined in this way is a neutral concept. The tanzimat and the problem of political authority in the. Part ii counters the consequentialist defense of the existence of the state by arguing that the expected consequences of anarchocapitalism are, at minimum, tolerable. Michael huemers immigration parable confessions of a. An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey michael huemer on. The political legitimacy of global governance institutions.
My main complaint about the problem of political authority is that its not long enough. Buy the problem of political authority by michael huemer with. A critique of michael huemers the problem of political authority danny frederick independent scholar 1. The interface between law and politics keynote address cape town 27 august 2010 kate oregan justice of the constitutional court 1994 2009 i introduction the constitution of the united states of america is 7000 words long. Dec 11, 2012 the problem of political authority is his best book yet. Modern political theory critically examines the contemporary. Modern political theory pdf modern political theory pdf modern political theory pdf download. The morally correct policy is the one that maximizes happiness. The social contract theory is the most prominent account of authority in the last 400 years of philosophy and has as good a claim as any to being americas theory of authority. The meaning of power and authority has been summarised by steven lukes 1978. International political authority and its politicization article pdf available in international theory 401. Mikael olsson in his 20 book the problem of political authority michael huemer attempts to defend the idea that states have no legitimate authority and that we should therefore move to an anarchic anarchocapitalist society.
I have little doubt the book will be a cornerstone of libertarian philosophy for years to come. Lincoln had political will in abundance, but so did hitler. The phrase political obligation is apparently no older than t. The first part of the book argues in detail for philosophical anarchism and refutes the legitimacy of political authority, while the second addresses political anarchism and the practical viability of.
Using moral premises you probably already accept, and clear but subtle arguments, huemer leads you stepbystep to a radical yet compelling conclusion. Mar 05, 2017 in the problem of political authority. Professor huemer, aaron, and trevor tackle problems of political obligation, political legitimacy, and political authority, and explain the differences between each of these terms. Lukes explains that, central to the idea of power is the notion of bringing about consequences, not unlike, for instance, the way in which your sociology teacher ensures that people. It is the first book on political philosophy ive read so wasnt sure what to expect but it is easy to read and not dependent on any abstract theory. The problem of political authority, by michael huemer 2012 was collecting dust on my bookshelf until a month ago. Political authority with a good sense of huemer part 1 of 2. The profile quoted huemer as saying that political authority is a moral illusion were suffering from. I received it from a friend around a year ago, and like most of my books, decided to keep it for later. Pdf international political authority and its politicization.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the problem of political authority. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Mar 04, 20 bryan caplan praises michael huemers work on the problem of political authority because it avoids the extremes of both rightsbased and consequentialist reasoning. An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey kindle edition by huemer, michael. The argument for political anarchy and antistatism is made by michael huemer in his book the problem of political authority. An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey, by michael huemer palgrave mcmillan 2012. Victim compensation this wont get off the ground until punishment paradigm is replaced until the wrong is thought to be between the offender and the victim not the offender and the state. The author discusses the problem of political authority in a common sens setting and how and why anarchocapitalism might be a better alternative. There is no political motivation for prisons to rehabilitate because they are expected to first and foremost punish. In considering the justification for the state, a nagging question naturally arises. Political authority direct democracy actual society deliberative democracy political legitimacy these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors.
An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey, by michael huemer palgrave mcmillan 2012 introduction the problem of political authority, by michael huemer 2012 was collecting dust on my bookshelf until a month ago. And yet, through careful reasoning that relies on commonly held ethical intuitions, huemer pulls off a. The two words from which green formed the phrase are much older, of course, and he apparently thought that combining them required no elaborate. The problem of political authority the problem of political authority, says huemer sec.
Nietzsche and weber on political attitudes to suffering introduction modern european ways of thinking about political authority and legitimacy have evolved over hundreds of years, largely in the context of different religious, predominantly christian, world views. In his book skepticism and the veil of perception, michael huemer lays out an account of perception that supports a version of direct realism. An orderly and livable society thus does not require acquiescence in the illusion of political authority. Huemer discusses the problems with political authority and the social contract i. The prima facie case most theories of distributive justice call for coercive redistribution of wealth on the part of the state on these views, the state should take money from the relatively wealthy, presumably via taxation, to enrich the relatively poor. Review of michael huemers the problem of political. Social contract theory and the problems of contract. Modern states commonly deploy coercion in a wide array of circumstances in which the resort to force would clearly be wrong for any private agent.
In his 20 book the problem of political authority michael huemer attempts to defend the idea that states have no legitimate authority and that we should therefore move to an anarchic anarchocapitalist society. The paperback of the the problem of political authority. Authority is the legitimate power which one person or group possesses and practices over another. Sovereignty, in modern terms, can refer either to the adherence to a form of sovereign rule or the individual sovereignty, or autonomy, of a nationstate. Review of huemer, the problem of political authority. The state is often ascribed a special sort of authority, one that obliges citizens to obey its commands and entitles the state to enforce those commands through threats of violence. Kant and hegel agree that normative claims are justified only if. I received it from a friend around a year ago, and. The problem of political authority is his best book yet.
The author goes on to discuss how voluntary and competitive institutions could provide the central goods for the sake of which the state is often deemed necessary, including law, protection from private criminals, and national security. Michael huemer, the problem of political authority. Whats missing in the problem of political authority. An examination of michael huemers book on the right to coerce and the duty to obey.
No one else is as clear, as accessible and as convincing as huemer is in the problem of political authority. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. The state is often ascribed a special sort of authority, one that obliges citizens to obey. How could a state have the moral authority to promulgate and enforce laws that citizens are thereby obliged to obey. Modern political theory pdf introduction to modern political thought. Professor huemer, aaron, and trevor tackle problems of political obligation, political legitimacy, and political authority, and explain the. If youre tired of political books that merely preach to the choir, prepare to be amazed. Michael huemer the problem of political authority an. Whats missing in the problem of political authority cato. Part one of huemer s book focuses on political authority, or whether states have a general moral right to coercively enforce their laws what huemer calls political legitimacy, and their citizens a general moral obligation to obey them political obligation. A civil state usually makes this formal by way of a judicial branch and an executive branch of government. If government does have this kind of authority, then the rest of us, conversely, have a duty to obey.
An examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey is a book by university of colorado philosophy professor michael huemer released in january 20. Jun 26, 2015 michael huemers 20 book the problem of political authority sets out to prove a radical conjecture. A few years ago i heard mike huemer give a talk on an argument that he was developing. This book argues that this notion is a moral illusion. Michael huemer on political authority justice and hedonism. See michael huemer, the problem of political authority. Part i powerfully critiques the morality of state authority. Taxation is not theft, because citizens have agreed to pay taxes. A case study of political dissidents and ethnic militia in nigeria dr adeyeye adewole 1 1senior lecturer, department of general and entrepreneurial studies ondo state university of science and technology, okitipupa, ondo state. In the problem of political authority, michael huemer levels a mighty challenge to the idea of political authority and what could take place in its stead.
Each has notoriously foundered on difficult problems in the past, as is wellknown to students of political philosophy. Michael huemer the problem of political authority an examination of the right to coerce and the duty to obey. The rest of society, with nonlibertarian political views, is more distrustful of. Political obligation stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. I recently read this book, and although it is generally interesting and wellwritten i have some criticisms to put forward. Huemers first task is to clarify his claim regarding direct awareness. The problem of political authority by huemer, michael ebook. The publisher has supplied this book in encrypted form. The social contract would also account for political legitimacy straightforwardly. Buy the problem of political authority by michael huemer. Mar 20, 20 bryan caplan praises michael huemers work on the problem of political authority because it avoids the extremes of both rightsbased and consequentialist reasoning.
371 945 1097 1586 1308 394 213 198 281 1056 578 462 1588 1484 594 1386 1339 1096 523 955 650 1504 1047 917 1426 1360 1142 29 1275 1052 304 812